Bhi Middle Island Real Estate & Homes

Our website features the best real estate search for homes, condos, land and foreclosure properties available in Bhi Middle Island, Bald Head Island NC. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes.

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood!

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Browse All Bhi Middle Island Properties for Sale

$899,000

100568495 MLS

Once in a while, a stunning property comes available. Tucked away on a rare and coveted stretch of Bald Head Island, on the North Carolina coast, 74 & 76 Cape Creek Road on Middle Island present a truly exceptional opportunity, two stunning lots offered together, surrounded by the ever-changing beauty of Cape Creek. Perched gracefully along the water's edge, this unique homesite captures sweeping marsh and creek views, where tidal rhythms, coastal breezes, and amazing sunrises create an unforgettable backdrop. With water on multiple sides, the property offers a sense of privacy and tranquility that is increasingly hard to find, making it ideal for a signature island retreat. Imagine designing a custom home that fully embraces the natural surroundings, expansive porches, panoramic windows, and seamless indoor-outdoor living, all oriented to take in the serene vistas and abundant wildlife that define life on Bald Head Island. Whether you envision a private family compound or a spacious estate with room to breathe, these combined lots provide the flexibility and scale to bring your vision to life. Located just moments from the island's pristine beaches, maritime forests, and world-class amenities, this offering pairs seclusion with convenience in one of the island's most picturesque settings. Create your dream island escape in one of Bald Head Island's most picturesque and peaceful settings. Contact BHI Club to ask about memberships.

74/76 Cape Creek Rd, Bald Head Island

$6,000,000

100566616 MLS

Tucked at the quiet end of Middle Island, this extraordinary offering presents a rare opportunity to acquire nine contiguous homesites encompassing a sweeping stretch of Bald Head Island's pristine marshfront. Thoughtfully assembled and offered as a single estate purchase, the property captures the essence of Lowcountry coastal living--unspoiled, expansive, and remarkably private. Overlooking a winding network of tidal creeks and vibrant salt marsh, the land offers panoramic water views that shift beautifully with the light and tides. From sunrise reflections across the marsh grasses to golden-hour skies over the distant Cape Fear River, the setting is both tranquil and dynamic. The natural landscape is rich with native vegetation and mature maritime forest, creating a sense of seclusion while still allowing for thoughtfully positioned homes to take full advantage of the views. Whether envisioned as a private family compound, a legacy purchase, or a curated residential enclave, the flexibility of nine individual lots provides a unique blend of scale and optionality rarely found on Bald Head Island. The location offers a peaceful retreat removed from the island's busier areas, yet remains convenient to beaches, the marina, and club amenities. This is a generational opportunity to secure a substantial piece of Bald Head Island's coastal beauty--where water, sky, and marsh converge in one of the island's most serene and captivating settings.

87 Cape Creek Rd, Bald Head Island

$345,000

100449611 MLS

MIDDLE ISLAND Marshfront over Half Acre Homesite facing Northeast viewing the Cape Creek waterway and 10,000 acres of the State Owned pristine Sanctuary, the property to the left - over an acre homesite was deeded to the Smith Island Land Trust. Lot 952 has large Live Oaks but located in a manner to build around; beautiful Palmetto & Sabal Palms. This homesite is ready to build your dream cottage. Just down the road; a short walk is a floating dock on Bald Head Creek with Kayak Stand for storage or bring your canoe over to enjoy the creeks. The Middle Island Marina is just down Cape Creek-Road with good deep tide water for ocean access. You have a private beach access to East Beach. Parklike Vegetation & privacy awaits you.

52 Cape Creek Rd, Bald Head Island

$10,500,000

100475505 MLS

Oceanfront & Marshfront. Sale of Tract B (177,070.21 square feet) as noted on Map Cabinet 160, Page 42 of the Brunswick County Registry. Lot located on private property accessible via private road.

31 E Beach Dr, Bald Head Island

$385,000

100422187 MLS

Introducing a picturesque lot nestled along the enchanting Cape Creek in Middle Island on Bald Head Island. This pristine property offers a unique opportunity to embrace coastal living at its finest, with breathtaking views that seamlessly blend the beauty of nature and the tranquility of the surroundings. Situated along the scenic Cape Creek, this lot boasts a prime location that allows you to immerse yourself in the serene ambiance of the island. The mesmerizing vistas of the creek create a captivating backdrop, offering a front-row seat to the ebb and flow of the tides and the soothing sounds of nature. Spanning a generous area of .639 of an acre, the lot provides ample space to envision and build your dream coastal retreat. Whether you aspire to design a charming beach cottage or a luxurious waterfront estate, the possibilities are as vast as the horizon visible from this splendid location. The lot's proximity to Middle Island ensures a sense of exclusivity and privacy, allowing you to relish in the peacefulness that Bald Head Island is renowned for. With the gentle rustle of the sea breeze and the warmth of the sun casting its glow, this property beckons those seeking a harmonious blend of coastal serenity and refined living. Embark on a journey to create your own haven where the beauty of Cape Creek converges with the allure of Middle Island. This is not just a property; it's an invitation to embrace the coastal lifestyle and savor the unparalleled beauty that defines Bald Head Island.

50 Cape Creek Rd, Bald Head Island

$683,000

100544179 MLS

Wide marshfront views • Exceptional privacy • Beautifully proportioned homesite With its broad marsh frontage and beautifully wooded approach, 83 Cape Creek Road offers an inviting canvas for a home designed to immerse you in Bald Head Island's natural beauty. This spacious lot overlooks a striking stretch of Cape Creek, where sculpted tidal channels and wide-open marsh plains create an ever-changing backdrop of color, wildlife, and reflected sky. The homesite sits slightly elevated and offers a more intimate, tucked-away feel than many parcels, with mature trees framing open water views to the west and southwest. It's ideally positioned for a residence that captures afternoon light, dramatic sunsets, and breezy outdoor living spaces oriented toward the marsh. With access to Middle Island's private dock, kayak launch, and tranquil natural environment, this property provides a setting that blends seclusion with adventure—perfect for those seeking a slower pace and a front-row seat to one of the island's most captivating ecosystems. Serene, spacious, and rich with possibility, 83 Cape Creek Road is an exceptional opportunity to build with nature as your daily inspiration.

83 Cape Creek Rd, Bald Head Island

$595,000

100544149 MLS

Signature waterfront perspective • Expansive building envelope • Incredible marshfront setting Positioned on one of Middle Island's most stunning stretches of Cape Creek, 85 Cape Creek Road offers a homesite that feels truly set apart. The property's generous width and gently curving rear boundary open onto an extraordinary sweep of tidal marsh and creek, with long, unbroken vistas across the preserved wetlands toward Bald Head's protected maritime forest. From an elevated build, you can potentially capture dramatic, panoramic views, where winding water channels glow at sunrise and the marsh grasses shift with every season. Nestled within mature hardwoods and pines, the lot provides natural privacy while still offering ample flexibility for a thoughtfully scaled residence, outdoor living terraces, and boardwalk-style pathways. Middle Island property owners enjoy access to the private boat and kayak launch, a quiet dock on the creek, and miles of serene natural surroundings unique to this side of Bald Head Island. Timeless, peaceful, and visually spectacular, 85 Cape Creek Road presents one of the most inspiring opportunities to create a custom coastal retreat on the island.

85 Cape Creek Rd, Bald Head Island

$3,850,000

5 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ 100531454 MLS

PRIVACY PRIVACY PRIVACY on this 2 ACRE COMPOUND with ELEVATED views of both MARSH and OCEAN a rare BHI Middle Island find. Tucked away on this 2 acre estate are 3 separate structures, the elegant main house, the charming 2 bedroom guest retreat and the screened pool house. DOCK access to private Middle Island. Showcasing Harry Watkins' design and Telesis' quality construction, with cooper roof these homes blend luxury, comfort and privacy with ocean breezes and panoramas to sea. The primary home's spacious, sun-drenched two-story living area offers a custom fireplace, wet bar, skylights, and wall of glass. Savor sunrises and nature scenes inside or on the extensive, secluded covered porch. The nearby handsomely appointed dining room boasts designer details, and its three sides of windows surround you with lush tableaus. Beyond the big, sunlit kitchen features a brand-new cooktop and ovens, as well as other professional-grade stainless appliances-including a wine cooler. You'll also appreciate the granite counters, generous island, walk-in pantry, and how it flows into the sunny breakfast space. Across is a bright Queen suite with a private bath. Farther, the huge Primary King has a large sitting area, masonry fireplace. The getaway's top floor houses a landing with an office and gathering spot, and a balcony offering ringside seating for watching marsh and Atlantic tides. From here, a ladder leads to a perch with views from the Atlantic to Southport! The home's lower level includes another bedroom with two Full beds, a bath with tub/shower, a workshop, and a craft room. The Guest Home's offers your guest or adult family true privacy with a light-filled central two-story living/dinning space with a sleeping loft and two suites each with private bath and porches. Conveying with three carts, this sanctuary grants an unparalleled lifestyle. Some exclusions. Inquire about club membership

15 Cape Creek Rd, Bald Head Island

$3,075,000

6 Beds ⋅ 7 Baths ⋅ 100468514 MLS

Overlooking Bald Head's estuary, with views of the Atlantic, this 6BR, 6.5BA reverse floorplan's warm hardwoods lead to a comfortable TV/living area across from a dinette. Wake to treats from the nearby coffee station with wet bar and mini fridge. Down the hall, a sunlit Queen suite grants marsh perspectives, accesses a screened porch housing a ping pong table and furnishes an ensuite BA. Next door, a bunk room also bestows BHI Creek scenes and uses the hall bath with tub. Nearby, a large, bright Twin suite, cornered by windows, harbors another full bath. Down the hall, a sundrenched corner Queen suite brings the outdoors in with its three sides of windows and indulges with a private bath. A laundry finishes this level. Upstairs, the natural light-filled, vaulted open floor plan showcases estuary panoramas and ocean vistas through its wall of French doors. The spacious wainscoted living area is anchored by a gas fireplace and opens to both a covered outdoor conversation space and a sunny lounging and dining deck. Savor alfresco meals observing egrets and watching the waves. Or dine at the elegant indoor table with places for ten and four more at the adjacent breakfast bar. The gourmet kitchen boasts yards of granite bar space, butcher block counters, stainless appliances and an oversize walk-in pantry. On each end of this floor is a Primary suite. The first tenders an ante chamber that can be closed off from the bedroom-proffering an additional gathering spot for all or closed to become a private sitting area. This sunlit Primary Queen shares marsh tableaus from three sides and a pampering bath with a sunken tub, benched shower and double vanity. The Primary King spotlights estuary and ocean prospects, accesses the covered deck and has a private full bath. Located on exclusive Middle Island, this well cared for, tastefully appointed sanctuary boasts a great rental history and conveys with three carts. Club memberships are available for separate purchase.

1 Dogwood Ridge Rd, Bald Head Island

$399,000

100477508 MLS

Middle Island is a world unto itself! Peaceful, serene, ''off the grid'' so to speak. MI provides a beautiful cacophony of natures music. The beautiful colors of nature's artwork dance across the marsh creek at sunset. And, from some areas, the powerful roar of the ocean calls you home. This lot boasts ideal views of the marsh creek. Beautiful trees and excellent site location. MI has a private dock and beach entrance.

16 Dogwood Ridge Rd, Bald Head Island

$380,000

100351900 MLS

51 Cape Creek Road is a beautiful lot located on the picturesque Bald Head Island, North Carolina. This unique property features breathtaking views of the Bald Head Creek and marsh, making it the perfect choice for anyone looking to build their dream home on a serene and peaceful island. The lot features ample space for a custom home, with plenty of room for outdoor living spaces and landscaping. It is located in a peaceful and friendly neighborhood of Middle Island, surrounded by lush greenery and natural beauty. With its close proximity to the beach, shopping, dining, and other island amenities, this lot is the perfect choice for those seeking a true island lifestyle. Whether you are looking to build a spacious family home, a cozy vacation getaway, or something in between, 51 Cape Creek Road is the perfect starting point. The adjoining lot is also available. Don't miss this opportunity to own a piece of paradise on one of the most beautiful islands in the world.

51 Cape Creek Rd, Bald Head Island

Start Your Search

Copyright 2026 NCRMLS. All rights reserved. North Carolina Regional Multiple Listing Service, (NCRMLS), provides content displayed here (“provided content”) on an “as is” basis and makes no representations or warranties regarding the provided content, including, but not limited to those of non-infringement, timeliness, accuracy, or completeness. Individuals and companies using information presented are responsible for verification and validation of information they utilize and present to their customers and clients. NCRMLS will not be liable for any damage or loss resulting from use of the provided content or the products available through Portals, IDX, VOW, and/or Syndication. Recipients of this information shall not resell, redistribute, reproduce, modify, or otherwise copy any portion thereof without the expressed written consent of NCRMLS.

8838 Tilbury Dr Wilmington, NC 28411 910-632-0060